St. John's secured the No. 2 position when Connecticut defeated Seton Hall in overtime, 62-60, on Wednesday night.
The Hoyas defeated Seton Hall, 73-62, on Jan. 27 when they pressed the Pirates into oblivion.
Randy Foye, who hit a last-second shot to defeat Seton Hall in the opening round, added 15 points.
Villanova defeated Seton Hall on Saturday.
The Rams have defeated Seton Hall, Vanderbilt and Xavier.
The Eagles, who finished the regular season with seven straight losses and were 9-18 over all, had done well by defeating seventh-seeded Seton Hall on Thursday.
In the second game of last night's doubleheader, 10th-seeded Boston College defeated seventh-seeded Seton Hall, 89-87.
Yesterday, the Orangemen defeated Seton Hall, 68-63.
But can Michigan defeat Seton Hall in a clash of overwhelming offense and unyielding defense?
The Huskies defeated Seton Hall twice in the regular season.